Problems in Mainstream Science

Plate Tectonics
Severity high
Mind Blown The earth is not only expanding, but it is ganing in mass meaning gravity has increased slowly over the millions of years

Plate tectonics in mainstream science has been disputed for over 100 years, with a growing number of scientists and geologists embracing alternative models. But of course, you don’t hear this on mainstream science media channels and websites.

Critical thinkers around the world are embracing what Dr. James Maxlow calls “expansion tectonics“. The major difference involves the radius of the Earth over billions of years. Plate tectonics states that the Earth has had the same radius for billions of years, while expansionists say the radius has been expanding.

It sounds like a small detail. It isn’t. If the expansionists are right, there was no giant ancient ocean around Pangaea, and the planet under your feet is still getting bigger today.

What the mainstream says

In plate tectonics, the Earth’s rigid outer shell is broken into plates that drift a few centimeters a year over a softer layer beneath. New sea floor is created where plates pull apart at mid-ocean ridges, and destroyed where one plate dives beneath another at “subduction zones”. Because crust is made and destroyed at the same rate, the Earth’s size stays the same. The plates are driven mainly by the pull of sinking slabs, helped by “ridge push” and by convection in the mantle.

The theory grew in the 1960s out of Alfred Wegener‘s 1912 idea of continental drift, which had been resisted for decades because it had no mechanism. Seafloor spreading supplied one. Its supporters point to the zebra-stripe magnetic patterns on the sea floor, the fact that no ocean floor anywhere is older than about 200 million years, GPS measurements of plates moving, and matching rocks and fossils on continents now separated by oceans.

To be fair, even the CNPS Wiki’s own Plate Tectonics article calls it among the best-confirmed theories in the earth sciences. It also notes that on the wiki itself, plate tectonics is the minority position: the Expansion Tectonics category holds nearly 300 pages.

The problems critics raise

Take away the assumption that the Earth’s radius never changes, expansionists argue, and the evidence fits a growing Earth better. Here is their case, along with the mainstream replies.

1. The jigsaw only closes on a smaller globe

Expansionists say the continents fit together not just across the Atlantic, as Wegener saw, but across all the oceans at once, on a globe about half the size, around 250 million years ago. Samuel Warren Carey, an early champion of continental drift, spent years trying to assemble Pangaea on an accurate model of today’s Earth and kept finding a “yawning gulf” between Indonesia and Australia. In the end, he concluded, “It was not my method that was at fault, but my assumption that the earth of Pangaea was the same size as the earth of today.”

Many researchers, from Hilgenberg‘s papier-mâché globes in 1933 to Vogel’s globe-within-a-globe in 1983 and Maxlow’s models, have built small Earths showing this. Creer remarked that the fit “appeared to be too good to be due to coincidence”. The wiki’s Plate Tectonics article agrees the global fit “is genuinely striking” and deserves a careful answer, though the mainstream explains it differently.

2. Where did all the sea floor go?

If the Earth stays the same size, all that new sea floor has to disappear somewhere, so plate tectonics needs subduction. Neal Adams did the bookkeeping in Subduction: The Extent and Duration (2011). Using the sea floor age map compiled by the National Geophysical Data Center, he found that new crust equal to the area of Africa has been added in each of the last 10-million-year slices, and argued that the subducted area is “far less than 1/20 of the spread area”. David de Hilster adds that Africa and Antarctica are ringed by spreading ridges with no subduction zones around them.

Interestingly, neither man denies subduction exists. Adams wrote that he “tried as hard as I could to deny that subduction was valid and profound. I could not do it.” They say there just isn’t enough of it. The mainstream answer, set out in the wiki’s review of Adams’s paper, is that subducted crust leaves no trace on a map of surviving crust, and that sinking slabs are seen directly in deep earthquake zones and seismic images reaching toward the core.

3. Reading the sea floor like tree rings

Since 1990, the Geological Map of the World has shown the age of every strip of sea floor, and none of it is older than about 170 million years. Maxlow compares the stripes to tree rings: peel them off one by one and you can measure how big the Earth used to be. Jan Koziar pioneered this in the early 1980s and measured a growth of 25.9 millimeters a year in Earth’s radius. Blinov got 19.9, and reworked figures from three other researchers give 20 to 23, for a mean of 22 millimeters a year, matching Maxlow’s own figure.

Mainstream geologists agree with the expansionists on how fast new crust is made. Their reply is that ocean floor is young because it’s recycled, while continents, which aren’t, reach nearly 4 billion years old.

4. Phantom oceans and wandering supercontinents

Conventional maps of the ancient Earth need huge oceans that no longer exist, such as Panthalassa, Iapetus and Tethys, to fill the space on a full-sized globe. On Maxlow’s small Earth models, these become shallow continental seas that later widened into today’s Pacific and Atlantic. He says his plates fit back together in only one way, unlike the many competing mainstream reconstructions.

5. Magnetic poles that line up

Ancient magnetism locked into rocks was used in the 1960s and 1970s to test whether the Earth had grown, and the answer was no. Maxlow argues those studies treated “virtual” pole locations as real ones. Plotted on his small Earth models, he says, ancient north and south poles cluster as true, diametrically opposite pairs, which de Hilster’s survey describes as impossible on plate tectonic reconstructions.

The mainstream points to published palaeomagnetic studies that find no significant change in radius; Schmidt and Clark obtained a ratio of ancient to present radius of 1.02 ± 0.06 at 400 million years ago.

6. Life and climate fit a smaller Earth

Expansionists argue that ancient climate zones, plants and animals line up more naturally on a smaller Earth. On Maxlow’s models, ancient carbonate reefs straddle the equator, glacial deposits sit around the ancient south pole, and trilobites could spread easily through connected shallow seas. David de Hilster’s survey The Growing Earth cites Dennis McCarthy’s argument about creatures that can’t cross oceans yet have relatives on both sides of the Pacific, such as the Fijian banded iguana, whose closest relatives live in California and Mexico.

7. Giants and gravity

Mechanical engineer Stephen Hurrell argues the largest dinosaurs, pterosaurs and giant insects would have been too heavy to move under today’s gravity. Strength grows with the square of size but weight with the cube, so gravity sets a ceiling on land life. From bone strength, trackways, blood pressure and even fossil feathers, he estimates ancient gravity at roughly half today’s. He says only an Earth that has gained mass fits, since an Earth that simply swelled at fixed mass would have had stronger gravity in the past. (See also our gravity problem page.)

Critics reply that sauropods are now estimated at 30 to 70 tonnes, and that air-filled bones, bird-like air sacs and column-like legs let them stand at today’s gravity.

8. Mountains without collisions

Plate tectonics builds mountains from colliding plates, and critics of expansion say a growing Earth could only stretch, never squeeze. Maxlow disagrees: as the radius grows, the surface flattens, and the continents must bend, buckle and fold to fit the new curvature. Features blamed on subduction are instead crust jostling as the Earth’s surface flattens out.

9. What do the satellites say?

This is where the two sides clash hardest, and the CNPS Wiki carries both views. According to Maxlow’s Expansion Tectonics article, when the global network of ground stations was completed in the early 1990s, it found an excess of 18 millimeters a year in Earth’s radius. The researchers recommended that vertical motion be “restricted to zero”, treating the excess as an atmospheric-correction error. Maxlow says global solutions are still effectively constrained to zero, and notes that 18 millimeters a year is close to his own 22 from sea floor areas. De Hilster’s 2008 survey also cites a Wuhan University study reporting at least 0.5 centimeters a year from ten years of GPS data, while admitting the measurements are “not congruent”.

The wiki’s Plate Tectonics article calls the geodetic data “the decisive difficulty” for expansion. It says space measurements now bound any change in Earth’s mean radius to about 0.1 ± 0.2 millimeters a year, consistent with zero and far below what expansion needs. The wiki’s reviews of Adams’s and Meyl’s papers trace that figure to a 2011 analysis by Wu and colleagues combining GPS, radio telescopes, satellite laser ranging and DORIS.

Alternative explanations

Mainstream geologists reply that there is no known way for the Earth to gain mass. Expansionists answer that continental drift was rejected for over 50 years for lack of a mechanism too. As de Hilster puts it, “a lack of a mechanism exists for gravity and light and yet we describe and accept the existence of both.” Still, several mechanisms have been proposed.

Maxlow points to charged particles from the solar wind, which he says the European Space Agency’s Cluster II satellites have shown entering the Earth in large quantities since 2000. He proposes they enter mainly at the polar auroral zones, are drawn to the core-mantle boundary, and recombine as new matter in the D” layer at the base of the mantle.

The de Hilsters propose that particles from their Particle Model enter mostly at the south pole and recombine into atoms within the Earth, which they say explains why the southern hemisphere has expanded more. In Earth Expansion Major Objections Solved (2016), David de Hilster argues that this uneven growth means some subduction should occur even on a growing Earth, answering both main objections at once.

Neal Adams proposed that “prime matter particles” are formed in the core by pair production and extended the idea to a growing universe. German engineer Konstantin Meyl, in Earth Expansion by Neutrino-Power (2015), argues that neutrinos absorbed in the core are converted into mass. The wiki’s own review of Meyl’s paper is sharply critical, calculating that even capturing every solar neutrino would fall many orders of magnitude short.

The New Concepts in Global Tectonics journal publishes critics of plate tectonics, and in 2011 Giancarlo Scalera of Italy’s national geophysics institute co-directed The Earth Expansion Workshop in Erice, Sicily, attended by Maxlow, Koziar and Hurrell. Scalera concluded that the history written on the ocean floor “is not the history of plate tectonics but the history of a planet that has expanded”.

Expansionists also say their work is routinely refused by publishers and peer reviewers who simply assume the Earth’s radius has never changed.

Critical thinkers working on this problem

  • Dr. James Maxlow: coined “expansion tectonics” in 1995, and his small-Earth models show all the continents fitting together like a jigsaw puzzle; Carey passed him the Expanding Earth “baton” in 1993.
  • Stephen Hurrell: plotted the largest land animals since the dinosaurs and argues they were so huge because gravity was lower on a smaller Earth.
  • Neal Adams: the comic book artist with his own growing-Earth theory, one of the builders of small-Earth models, whose animations reached millions.
  • Bob de Hilster and David de Hilster: propose a Particle Model mechanism for how the Earth gains mass; David also wrote Dinosaurs and the Expanding Earth.
  • Samuel Warren Carey (1911–2002): the “modern father” of the Expanding Earth, who found Pangaea would not close on today’s globe.
  • Jan Koziar: Polish geologist who pioneered measuring sea floor areas to calculate Earth’s past radius.

Further reading on the CNPS Wiki

Read more on the CNPS Wiki.

Loading

by Stephen Hurrell
Those of us who have studied ancient gravity in detail generally agree the evidence indicates gravity was much less in the geological past. I even think we can roughly calculate that ancient gravity was about half of today’s gravity 200 million years ago, slowly increasing over hundreds of millions of years to reach its present day level. >>>think critically...
by David de Hilster
Did you ever wonder why animals and plants were so huge millions of years ago? It seems that our fascination with the world of the dinosaurs and their sizes is so fascinating, that we forget to ask the "biggest" question. >>>think critically...
by David de Hilster
This video could change everything you think about modern science and physics. It's implications are huge and watching them over and over to see how all the continents fit together is addictive! >>>think critically...

Technical Papers & Abstracts (Count: 94)

Page:1234
Page:1234

Books (Count: 35)

Page:12
Page:12