Problems in Mainstream Science
Our math system is wrong? The one perfect system humans have created, and probably the most useful system in human history? You’re telling me our math is wrong?
Yep. In fact, when creating new models for the universe, it has become obvious to many critical thinkers that our math system, and especially negative numbers, are not real in the universe. People like Peter Erickson and scientist and model builder Bob de Hilster will tell you: our math system needs some tweaking.
What the mainstream says
What we learn in school is called the “real number system”. It was given its rigorous modern form in the 1870s, chiefly by Dedekind and Cantor, and it underlies calculus and every equation in physics that uses a continuous quantity. It is a line of numbers with no gaps, and that “no gaps” property is exactly what calculus needs to work.
The infinitely small was tamed the same way. Newton and Leibniz built calculus on infinitesimals; in the 1800s Weierstrass replaced them with the limit, and in 1960 Robinson’s non-standard analysis gave infinitesimals a rigorous home of their own. Mathematicians point out that the system’s odd features, such as the fact that most real numbers can never be listed, are proven theorems, not oversights. Any replacement has a high bar to clear: it has to reproduce all of calculus and the equations of physics that match experiment so well.
The problems
Although the real number system is extremely useful in all of human endeavors, there are some areas where it breaks down:
- dividing by zero
- the square root of a negative number
- representing the physical world
The critics, gathered on the CNPS Wiki under Foundations of Mathematics, don’t all agree with each other. Some attack the infinite, some the negative, and some the way physics leans on math. Here are their main arguments.
1. Is anything in nature negative?
David de Hilster, a mathematician by training, argues in “The Veritable Number System” (2018) that negative numbers have no counterpart in the physical universe. No collection has fewer than none of something. No rod is shorter than no length. Every minus sign in physics, he argues, is really a direction (west instead of east), or a shortfall measured from a zero someone chose. Minus 40 degrees Celsius is 233 degrees on the absolute Kelvin scale, which has no negatives at all. Even “negative” electric charge is just Benjamin Franklin’s label; he could have called the two kinds north and south, as we do for magnets.
His father Bob de Hilster reached the same place from the workbench. In “No Negatives in Physical Electronic Circuits & Physics Itself” (2019), writing as an electrical engineer who spent a career designing circuit boards, he argues that there are no negative numbers in physics, only directions: a sine wave dips below zero half the time, but what is really there is an “up” amplitude and a “down” amplitude, each with a size.
History backs up the suspicion. Negative numbers were resisted longer than any other kind of number. Brahmagupta made sense of them in the seventh century by treating them as debts. Descartes still called them “false roots” in the 1600s, and as late as 1831 the mathematician De Morgan was calling them absurd in print. They were accepted because they were useful, and explained afterwards. The wiki’s article on Negative quantities works through the hard cases, from antimatter to negative temperature.
2. Minus times minus: proof or convention?
Why is a negative times a negative a positive? Jack Kuykendall started asking around 2000, and found the classic textbook “What Is Mathematics?” by Courant and Robbins saying the rule was set up to preserve the distributive law and “cannot be ‘proved'”. In “Flaws with Our Current Mathematical System” he argues that mathematicians should have treated this as a problem, and instead invented imaginary numbers and absolute values to get around it. He also objects that the minus sign does too many jobs at once: subtraction, direction, division in an exponent, and more.
Peter Erickson likewise argues in “The Nature of Negative Numbers” (2011) that the law of signs is a convention. Here the critics split. David de Hilster, while agreeing that nothing in nature is negative, argues that the rule is a theorem: it follows from the distributive law and the uniqueness of additive inverses, and he proves it in an appendix. What can be questioned, he says, is whether multiplication must distribute over addition at all.
3. The square root of minus one
The square root of a negative number has no meaning as an amount of anything. Mathematics lives with it either as a strange quantity of another order or as a mere instruction to perform an operation. Erickson rejects both. In his Veritable Number System the minus one under the root sign comes from a different number system altogether, one in which positive and negative numbers are incompatible and cannot simply cancel out.
David de Hilster offers a third reading in “Rotation Without the Imaginary Unit” (2026). Nature shows no negative quantities, he concludes, but it does show reversal: turning something around, which done twice gets you back where you started. Reversal is an operation, not an amount. Read that way, the square root of minus one is a quarter turn in an oriented plane, and “i squared equals minus one” becomes a theorem about handedness rather than a mysterious axiom.
4. Dividing by zero, and what zero is
Division by zero is the first of the two holes David de Hilster names. Erickson argues in Division in the Veritable Number System that division is more versatile in his system, and that division by zero becomes valid under statable conditions once space is understood as made of indivisible infinitesimals.
Viktor N Moroz questions zero itself. In “The Vicious Circle: Mathematics – Physics” he calls zero “the declaration of the existence of the non-existent”, and separates three meanings of it: physical emptiness, the dimensionless geometric point, and the digit, which he holds conflict with each other.
5. Infinity: finished or never-ending?
The real numbers are built from completed infinite sets: a Dedekind cut is a finished infinite set, a Cauchy sequence a finished infinite list. Aristotle allowed only potential infinity, the ability to keep going without end, and denied that any finished infinite totality exists. If he was right, critics argue, the reals as defined do not exist either. Cantor made the actual infinite a legitimate mathematical object, and mathematics has run on it since.
The wiki’s Infinity article collects the dissent. Velimir Abramovic says reading Cantor’s diagonal argument convinced him that nothing in it can be taken for granted. Thomas E Phipps argues that the usual value of an infinite series is a convention, not a discovery. Moroz goes furthest, calling infinity a “finite infinity” and the infinitesimal “equal and not equal to zero at the same time”.
6. Numbers that can never be written down
Cantor’s diagonal argument shows that the real numbers cannot be listed. The price is that almost every real number has no finite description, no formula and no algorithm. Yet every measurement returns a finite decimal, every instrument has a resolution, and no experiment has ever produced an uncomputable number. Critics ask in what sense such numbers belong in physics at all. Mainstream mathematicians reply that the continuum can be treated as a modelling device, which, the wiki notes, concedes the critics’ underlying point: the math outruns what physics can claim.
7. Infinitesimals and the limit
Newton and Leibniz built calculus with infinitely small quantities, which Bishop Berkeley mocked in 1734 as “ghosts of departed quantities”. In the 1800s they were replaced by the idea of a limit. Peter Erickson argues in The Nature of Infinitesimals (2012) that the limit “conceals a real problem rather than solving it”, that space is made of indivisible infinitesimals, and that time is made of discrete instants. On his account there is “no microscopic infinity”.
8. Math standing in for physics
The broadest complaint is not about numbers at all. Moroz describes a closed loop: mathematics lacks a secure foundation, physicists trust it anyway and build abstract theories detached from nature, and those theories are then “confirmed” by experiments read through the same math. Evert Jan Post made the same charge from inside physics in “Mathematical Alchemy in Physics“, warning of a “near-magic confidence” that mathematics can rescue conceptual leaps that are not themselves logical.
The result, critics say, shows up as infinities inside accepted theories, such as the point-mass singularity of general relativity and the infinite self-energy of the electron, which are then removed by hand. And it shows up as a loss of physicality: theories that predict without saying what things are made of. As David de Hilster put it in a 2023 session, “Math has taken over physics. We spend a majority of our time working on equations. What about physicality? Have we neglected it?” See our Relativity and Quantum Mechanics pages for where this bites.
Alternative explanations
Some critical thinkers go beyond criticism and propose new math. Peter Erickson’s “veritable number system”, set out in “The Nature of Negative Numbers”, treats positive and negative numbers as incompatible, so they can’t simply cancel out. Jack Kuykendall proposes “Symmetry-Math“, which keeps the minus sign only for subtraction and writes directions as an arrow plus a size, removing negative numbers, imaginary numbers and absolute values.
David de Hilster put Symmetry-Math to the test by building a signless notation to Kuykendall’s rules and running it against complex numbers and geometric algebra. He found it better than complex numbers for combining rotations, worse for adding points, and lacking any rule for combining rotations in three dimensions. His verdict: the diagnosis behind Symmetry-Math is sound, but the remedy stops one step short of its target, which is to treat reversal as an operation on an oriented plane, as geometric algebra does.
Others look at different pieces. Jeffrey N Cook proposes a missing operation, “submission”, or repeated self-division, in “Annarithms and Opponents” (2026). Glenn Borchardt‘s neomechanics supplies a general test: “matter exists; motion occurs”, so a negative amount of matter is not merely unobserved but incoherent.
The mainstream has its own alternatives too. Constructive and finitist mathematics, which reject the completed infinite, are live research areas, as is non-standard analysis. The wiki notes that they do much of the work but are harder and less complete. And to be fair, most of the replacements proposed by critics have not yet been tested against the standard of reproducing all of calculus and physics. That is the price of entry, and it is what the critics are working toward.
Critical thinkers working on this problem
- David de Hilster: argues negative numbers have no physical counterpart, in “The Veritable Number System” (2018), and tested Symmetry-Math against complex numbers.
- Bob de Hilster: scientist and model builder whose Particle Model work led him to argue there are no negative numbers in physics, only directions.
- Dr. Glenn Borchardt: insists on an actual infinity in nature, and holds that only matter exists, so nothing can be less than nothing.
- Stephen Crothers: argues the infinitely dense point-mass of general relativity is an artifact of a wrong analysis.
- Dr. Charles William Lucas: counts physics’ “problems with infinities” among the symptoms of postulates known to be false.
- Peter F Erickson: philosopher of mathematics behind the veritable number system and the indivisible infinitesimal.
- Jack Kuykendall: creator of Symmetry-Math, a number system without negative or imaginary numbers.
Further reading on the CNPS Wiki
- Foundations of Mathematics: the real numbers, what is disputed, and the case for the orthodoxy
- Mathematics: a short index of the disputes over math on the wiki
- Negative quantities: whether any minus sign in physics names something real
- Infinity: potential versus actual infinity, in math and in physics
- Veritable Number System: Erickson’s third way of handling direction in number
- The Nature of Negative Numbers: Erickson’s book-length case
- The Nature of Infinitesimals: Erickson on the indivisible infinitesimal
- The Veritable Number System: David de Hilster’s 2018 article on negative numbers
- No Negatives in Physical Electronic Circuits & Physics Itself: Bob de Hilster’s 2019 article
- Rotation Without the Imaginary Unit: A Comparative Test of Three Notations for Euler’s Formula: Symmetry-Math put to the test
- Symmetry-Math (SM): Kuykendall’s paper
- Flaws with Our Current Mathematical System: Kuykendall’s live session on the rule of signs
- The Vicious Circle: Mathematics – Physics: Moroz on zero, infinity and the math-physics loop
- Mathematical Alchemy in Physics: Post on physics’ faith in mathematics
- Physicality: the demand that physics say what things are made of
Read more on the CNPS Wiki.
![]()




