Problems in Mainstream Science
Ask a physicist what time is and you may hear that it is a fourth dimension, woven together with space, that stretches and slows for anything moving fast. Send one twin off on a fast rocket and she comes home younger than her brother. We are told the GPS in every phone proves it daily.
Yet some of the people who know clocks best have never been convinced. Louis Essen, who built the first practical caesium atomic clock, spent decades arguing that special relativity was conceptually confused. Ron Hatch, one of the principal algorithm designers of GPS, argued that GPS counts against Einstein, not for him. Few of these critics dispute that moving clocks tick differently. The fight is over what that means: is time itself slowing down, or just the clocks?
What the mainstream says
In 1905 Einstein derived a formula for time dilation: a clock moving relative to you accumulates less time than your own, by the Lorentz factor. Because the formula depends only on relative velocity, the effect is mutual. Each of two observers in steady relative motion finds the other’s clock running slow. In the same paper Einstein claimed that a clock sent on a round trip comes back having recorded less time than one that stayed home. Paul Langevin’s 1911 retelling with human twins gave the “twin paradox” its name. The standard resolution points to the traveller’s turnaround.
General relativity adds a second effect: a clock lower in a gravitational field runs slower than one higher up. Time becomes one coordinate of a four-dimensional spacetime.
The textbook evidence rests on a few pillars. Muons made by cosmic rays 10 to 15 km up should, with a lifetime of 2.2 microseconds, travel only about 660 metres on average, yet they reach the ground in large numbers. In 1971 Hafele and Keating flew caesium clocks east and west around the world. GPS satellite clocks are deliberately offset before launch: about 45 microseconds a day fast from weaker gravity, about 7 slow from speed, 38 net. Modern optical clocks, mainstream physicists add, detect both effects in the laboratory.
The problems
Our Relativity Problems page gives the short version of these objections. Here we dig into what they say about time itself.
1. Slower clocks are not slower time
The CNPS Wiki’s Time Dilation article puts it plainly: the dispute is rarely about the numbers. Most critics accept that moving clocks behave differently. What they reject is the leap from “this clock ticked slower” to “time itself slowed”.
Joseph Levy argues in “Aether-Theory Clock Retardation vs Special Relativity Time Dilation” that clocks tick slower because they move through the aether, while time itself is untouched. Thomas Barnes and Francisco Ramirez made the same swap in “Velocity Effects on Atomic Clocks and the Time Question“.
2. Dingle’s Question: which clock is slower?
Herbert Dingle, a former President of the Royal Astronomical Society and author of a standard relativity textbook, argued from the 1950s that the theory makes two clocks in uniform relative motion each run slower than the other, which is impossible. In Science at the Crossroads (1972) he boiled this down to “The Question”: if one clock must work steadily slower, how is the slower clock distinguished? His proof, he wrote, had been treated “in every possible way except that of answering it”.
Historian Hasok Chang reviewed the whole controversy in 1993 and concluded that Dingle’s opponents had not actually rebutted his argument. Defenders of relativity reply that the two slow-clock formulas describe different pairs of events, so there is no contradiction. Dingle’s formulation is still restated and defended in the dissident literature.
3. The twin paradox has too many answers
If time dilation is mutual, why does only one twin come home younger? The wiki’s Twin paradox article follows Nick Percival, who has worked on the problem for more than fifty years. His project found that papers in top physics journals give 21 different, mutually exclusive causes for the age difference, and that the journals have published rebuttals of none of them.
The acceleration answer has problems of its own, critics say. Let the stay-at-home twin copy every acceleration of the traveller and the standard calculation gives virtually the same age gap. Give two travellers identical turnarounds but trips differing a hundredfold and the “same” acceleration must have a hundred times the effect. Around 2011 about 150 physicists signed an open letter saying the paradox deserves serious analysis; Percival reported the mainstream response in a 2012 update. Percival also proposed “A Very Doable Experiment For NASA To Look Inside The Twin Paradox“: everyone agrees on the total age gap, so measure how it builds up during the trip.
4. What GPS clock corrections really show
GPS does correct its satellite clocks. The question is how. Every satellite and receiver shares one common time in a single Earth-centred frame. Ron Hatch argued in “Relativity and GPS – I” and later papers that this amounts to absolute simultaneity, which special relativity denies. Percival notes that the corrections use each clock’s speed relative to that one frame, not the speed of one clock relative to another. Harry Ricker points out that the satellite clocks are corrected but the ground receivers get no matching correction: lopsided slowing, not mutual.
The wiki’s GPS article adds a nuance. The famous 38 microseconds a day is nearly the same for every satellite, so a receiver would absorb most of it into its own clock error. But the smaller correction for each satellite’s slightly oval orbit cannot be absorbed, and every receiver applies it. Mainstream physicists add that once a frame is chosen, the asymmetry is exactly what relativity predicts.
5. The Hafele–Keating data
Hafele and Keating never published their raw data. Keating later gave it to mathematician Domina Eberle Spencer, who analysed it with Uma Shama and Philip Mann in “A New Interpretation of the Hafele-Keating Experiment” (1996). They found the clocks drifted along curves, yet the analysis assumed straight-line drift during the flights. In their words, “curves which are never linear when they can be measured do not suddenly become linear when they cannot be measured.” Individual clocks gave shifts of both signs. The data, they argued, fit Spencer’s “universal time” postulate, with no mutual time dilation at all.
Alphonsus G Kelly went further in “Hafele and Keating Tests: Did They Prove Anything?“, arguing the published figures differed radically from the actual results. The wiki’s own assessment calls the criticism of the 1971 analysis fair. Mainstream physicists answer that the flights were repeated in 1996 and 2005, and that modern clocks measure the effect far more precisely.
6. Muons: lifetime depends on speed, but relative to what?
Few critics deny that fast muons survive longer. Donald T MacRoberts argued in “The ‘Time Dilation’ of Mesons Re-Examined” that the lifetime depends on velocity relative to the Earth and has nothing to do with relativity’s time dilation. Thierry De Mees offers a physical cause, a gravitomagnetic self-induction effect, and notes that relativity itself never supplies a mechanism. Al Kracklauer reports that the muon effect is a perspective effect that does not produce unequal ageing.
The mainstream reply is strong: a CERN storage ring measured the effect for muons undergoing enormous acceleration, showing it tracks speed, not acceleration. See the wiki’s Muon article.
7. Is time even a dimension?
Spacetime treats time as a direction you could travel along. Glenn Borchardt calls this “the objectification of motion”. Time, he says, is not a thing or a container but the motion of matter itself, and he compares spacetime to the old caloric theory, which mistook a process for a substance. His slogan: “matter exists; motion occurs.”
Percival reached a similar place from the twin paradox. In “Time Does Not Have Dimensionality Or Even A Separate Physical Existence” he concludes that proper time, what a clock actually accumulates, is all physics needs, and that time has no separate existence. The question reaches into the mainstream too: physicist Julian Barbour argues in The End of Time that time is not fundamental at all.
Alternative explanations
Real clock slowing in a preferred frame. The most common alternative keeps the numbers and drops the metaphysics. Levy, Percival and Hatch argue that clocks slow according to their absolute speed relative to a single frame or aether, as in Lorentz’s theory. Hatch developed a Modified Lorentz Ether Theory that keeps absolute simultaneity while letting clocks run at different rates.
A different reading of the equations. Steven Bryant argues time dilation, length contraction and the twin paradox all come from reading wavelength-based observations with length-based equations, and offers Modern Mechanics as a replacement. Nizar Hamdan derives the key relativistic equations for charged particles from the Lorentz force law, with no time dilation at all.
An equation is not a phenomenon. Ricardo Carezani’s Autodynamics accepts the clock and muon measurements and even the formula, but in “Time Dilation and Autodynamics” denies any “automatic” slowing of moving clocks. A decay measures “the time that the phenomenon consumed”, and with only one reference system there is no twin paradox.
Mass, momentum and motion. James Carter argues clocks change rate because their mass changes. Viraj Fernando traces GPS clock-rate changes to internal momentum in “Internal Momentum Changes Manifesting as Clock Rate Changes in GPS Clocks“.
Critical thinkers working on this problem
- Nick Percival: more than fifty years on the twin paradox; argues GPS, Hafele–Keating and muon data support lopsided clock slowing, not time dilation, in “Data That Allegedly Proves Special Relativity Disproves It“.
- Ron Hatch: GPS pioneer, creator of the Hatch filter, who argued GPS runs on absolute simultaneity; author of Escape from Einstein.
- Harry Hamlin Ricker III: author of the “Herbert Dingle Was Correct!” series and “Empirical Verification of Time Dilation in Special Relativity“, which argues GPS practice contradicts mutual time dilation.
- Steven Bryant: argues in “The Twin Paradox: Why it is Required by Relativity” that time dilation and the twin paradox come from confusing length with wavelength.
- Ricardo Carezani: his Autodynamics accepts the clock data but rejects time dilation as an automatic property of moving clocks.
- Dr. Glenn Borchardt: argues time is the motion of matter, not a dimension, and disputes the muon argument in “Solution to the Muon Paradox“.
- James Carter: argues in “The Dual Effects of Both Gravity and Absolute Motion on the Rate of Clocks” that clock rates follow mass changes and absolute motion.
- Dr. Cynthia Whitney: wrote “The Twins, the Mesons, and the Paradox” on why a prediction that seems confirmed by long-lived mesons still leads to a paradox.
Further reading on the CNPS Wiki
- Time: the concept, how it is measured, and the main disputes.
- Time Dilation: the full archive of critiques, from 1959 to today.
- Twin paradox: the 21 reconciliation arguments and Percival’s project.
- Herbert Dingle: the life and the “Dingle Question”.
- GPS: which clock corrections matter and which could be absorbed.
- Simultaneity: why clock synchronisation is at the heart of it all.
- Muon: the particle behind the textbook proof.
- A New Interpretation of the Hafele-Keating Experiment: Spencer’s look at the raw data.
- The Hafele-Keating Contradiction: Dennis McCarthy on the choice of reference frame.
- Those Scandalous Clocks: Hatch on clock biases in GPS, VLBI and pulsar timing.
Read more on the CNPS Wiki.

