Problems in Mainstream Science

Stars
Severity high
Mind Blown What are stars really made of?

As much as we think we know about stars in mainstream science, there are problems. What a star is actually made of is still up for grabs. Is it a ball of hot gas? Liquid metal? A giant electrical discharge? Or a young planet?

Here you will find those who propose different models for stars.

What the mainstream says

In the standard picture, a star is a ball of hot, gaseous plasma powered by nuclear fusion in its core. Stars form when clouds of gas collapse under gravity, and planets form separately from the leftover disc of dust and gas. Stars of different masses follow different life paths: the most massive burn out first, and stars end their lives as white dwarfs, neutron stars or black holes. Stars and planets are treated as two completely different kinds of object.

The problems critics raise

Critical thinkers have challenged almost every part of that picture, from what powers a star to what it is made of.

  • Not a fusion furnace? In 1972 Ralph Juergens proposed that the Sun is the focus of a cosmic electric discharge rather than a fusion furnace. This became the founding idea of the Electric Universe, which holds that stars are powered by electric currents flowing through galaxies.
  • Born by pinching. In the Electric Universe view, stars form when electric currents in space, called Birkeland currents, pinch matter together, with the elements sorted by a process known as Marklund convection.
  • Not a gas at all? Dr. Pierre-Marie Robitaille argues the Sun is not a gaseous plasma but is built from condensed liquid metallic hydrogen. With Stephen Crothers, he also argues that stars are not gaseous at all.

Stellar Metamorphosis: stars are young planets

One of the boldest alternatives is “stellar metamorphosis“, proposed since 2012 by independent researcher Jeffrey Wolynski. He argues that stars and planets aren’t two kinds of object at all, but one object seen at different ages. In his words, “Planets are ancient stars and stars are young planets.”

Wolynski calls the assumption that stars and planets are different “the root assumption” of astrophysics, and says no evidence was ever offered for it. On his account, a young star is a hot, electrically charged ball, like “ball lightning on large scales”. As it ages, it cools, shrinks and changes color, passing through red dwarf, brown dwarf and gas giant stages, until its material settles out as rock, oceans and air. The result is an Earth-like world, and eventually a dead body like the Moon. Even the word “planet” supports him, he notes: it comes from the Greek for “wandering star”.

The idea reaches far beyond astronomy. Wolynski argues that the Earth was once a giant ball of plasma much larger than today, that its hot lava is heat left over from billions of years of cooling, and that oil formed as hydrocarbon rain when Earth was the size of Jupiter or Saturn. He presented the theory at the 20th Natural Philosophy Alliance Conference in 2013.

Stellar metamorphosis isn’t accepted in mainstream astronomy, and even other critical thinkers don’t endorse it. Electric Universe supporters share its rejection of fusion but don’t claim stars turn into planets, and Robitaille’s liquid-metal Sun says nothing about stars becoming planets. Its critics point to hard questions, such as how a hydrogen-rich star could end up as an iron-and-rock planet like Earth. But it does put a spotlight on a question almost no one asks: where exactly is the line between a star and a planet? Brown dwarfs, which start out hot and glowing, include examples colder than the Earth’s surface.

Critical thinkers working on this problem

  • Dr. Pierre-Marie Robitaille: argues stars are not gaseous but are made of condensed liquid metallic hydrogen.
  • Wal Thornhill: a leader of the Electric Universe movement, which sees stars as electrical objects rather than fusion furnaces.
  • Stephen Crothers: argues with Robitaille that stars are not gaseous.

Read more on the CNPS Wiki.

Loading

by Pierre Robitaille
Our Sun has confronted humanity with overwhelming evidence that it is comprised of condensed matter. Dismissing this reality, the standard solar models continue to be anchored on the gaseous plasma. >>>think critically...